Recently, with the anniversary
of the Beatles first visit to America, the question has again arisen as
to who played the first Beatles record in the U.S. In October, 2002,
I recevied this series of emails from The60sshop@aol.com. The series of
5 emails appears here now. (I did not copy the graphics of old surveys
or records mentioned) Hopefully this will answer the question of...
"Who played the very first BEATLES record here in the United States???" The debate has been going on for YEARS...more than a few stations have laid claim to having been the first. (The ones most commonly cited are WINS in New York, home of self-proclaimed "5th Beatle" MURRAY THE K, and WWDC... out of Washington, D.C., where THE BEATLES played their first US concert. You'll also hear WABC out of New York mentioned from time to time.) In the interest of providing our list with the truth (and finally giving credit and recognition where it is really due), we've taken on the project of settling, once and for all, the answer to this oft-asked question.
However, to really come up with the answer to this question, we need to
work backwards.
The highly-acclaimed EXCELLENT Beatles' biography SHOUT by PHILIP NORMAN states:
A disc jockey in Washington, D.C., working on station WWDC, had somehow
obtained a copy of I WANT TO HOLD YOUR HAND, and was playing it on the
air amid a commotion of interest from his listeners. The record had
come not from Capitol but from London via the disc jockey's girl
friend, who was a stewardess with British Overseas Airways. "Capitol
wanted to get clearance on the publishing side, to be able to ship a few
hundred copies into the Washington area," Walter Hofer says. "In
fact, I had to tell them that the publishing rights had been sold to another
company, MCA. Sold for almost nothing, it so happened, just to give
the song any foothold that was possible over here."
However, as we ALL know, I WANT TO HOLD YOUR HAND was NOT the first BEATLES record to be released here in the United States. This was their BREAKTHROUGH hit, but earlier releases of PLEASE PLEASE ME, FROM ME TO YOU and SHE LOVES YOU (on the much smaller, independent labels VeeJay and Swan), were released first with little or no fanfare. So, whereas WWDC can certainly lay claim to breaking THE BEATLES' first HIT record, I WANT TO HOLD YOUR HAND, they were NOT the first radio station in the country to play a BEATLES tune on the radio. (Likewise, EVERYBODY remembers the first appearance of THE BEATLES on THE ED SULLIVAN SHOW...it was watched by a record-breaking number of people...but it was NOT their first U.S. television appearance. Before Ed booked the band, they had already been featured on THE JACK PAAR SHOW and in a news segment with WALTER CRONKITE...but it was the ED SULLIVAN appearance that got all the attention!) ***
Hi There,
Once the Capitol Marketing Machine kicked in, there was no stopping the
furor...
BTW: In yet another case of misjustice, Carnegie Hall has often been credited as the first U.S. venue to house a BEATLES concert. The very fact that a ROCK group would be allowed to perform at such a prestigious (read "snooty") venue was amazing at the time. (Forget the fact that they had already performed at London's Palladium and in front of British Royalty!) Promoter SID BERNSTEIN may have distorted the truth a little bit (as to just what TYPE of British musicians these guys really were) when he secured a booking for the Carnegie Hall appearances to coincide with their Sullivan debut...but all of this was AFTER their first U.S. concert was held at the Washington, D.C. Coliseum. PART 2: We'll have
more on this tomorrow, as we trace back just a little bit further in our
quest to see which radio station FIRST played THE BEATLES here in America...
September 28, 1963 The legendary New York disc jockey Murray The K, receives a copy of The Beatles' "She Loves You" and plays it on the radio. It is believed to be the first Beatles song ever played in the U.S. It's exactly THIS type of thing that has inspired us in our quest to establish the truth. Unfortunately, bits of information like this get picked up, circulated, accepted and then repeated as "fact"...as this special feature report on the first radio station to play a BEATLES record in the United States will prove, the above claim is ludicrous! ***
***
I am sure SOMEONE played Please Please Me in the USA in early 1963. I know I heard She Loves You via the stations in Toronto in late November and early December via CKEY and CHUM. Clay I remember reading that THE BEATLES caught on in Canada earlier than here in the States...and know that some Canadian pressings of their singles (most notably ALL MY LOVIN' and ROLL OVER BEETHOVEN) actually sold well enough here as IMPORTS to make the American Charts! ***
***
This was still hardly the American break-through the band was hoping for. The general feeling at the time was that British acts just were NOT going to make it here. In that DEL SHANNON's version of FROM ME TO YOU had already charted, it is very possible, in hindsight, to consider that THE BEATLES' version may have been viewed as a "remake" instead of as the original. (By 1963. DEL SHANNON was already an established artist and, based on the low-charting of his version, THE BEATLES' version was likely not added to very many playlists.) In any event, the fact that FROM ME TO YOU received enough sales and airplay to hit #116, PROVES that SOMEBODY here in the United States was playing a BEATLES record on the radio...well before SHE LOVES YOU...and well before I WANT TO HOLD YOUR HAND. Read on tomorrow...this is FAR from over!!! In my research preparing for this special series, I've come across some reprint articles from The St. Louis Post Dispatch that help to chronicle these "new" events. However, this article ran in 1997...five years before Louise Harrison made that revelation in PEOPLE MAGAZINE. If any part of this article is true, this predates the more common belief as to who played the first BEATLES record by several months. Read on... From St. Louis Post-Dispatch
-
In
the quiet of September 1963, Beatle George Harrison visited his sister
in Southern Illinois, where a teen-age DJ first put needle to Beatles vinyl
-- months before the group's milestone "Ed Sullivan" gig. Now a local
fan wants history to remember Harrison's musical recom mission -- and the
time.
Quite honestly, if ANY part of this story is true, it completely changes
the broadcast history of THE BEATLES here in America. Imagine...a
young, 20-year old GEORGE HARRISON playing FROM ME TO YOU on the radio
and then jammin' with some local band in downstate rural Illinois!!!
What a shock THAT must have been! (Those of you who were on the list
a year ago and remember our week-long tribute to the BEATLES' first appearance
on THE ED SULLIVAN SHOW will remember that there was every bit as much
reaction to THE BEATLES' hair as there was to their music!!! Imagine
the look on the local Benton folks' faces down in what could pretty much
be described as "Hicksville, USA", when they first laid eyes on long-haired
Beatle-George!)
BTW: SPEAKING OF THE HOUSE IN BENTON, IL: Louise Harrison has called
off a fund-raising effort to help save a house in Benton, Ill., where her
brother, Beatle George Harrison, once stayed. Louise Harrison lived in
the house in 1963. Her brother visited her there for a couple weeks shortly
before gaining fame in the United States. Civic officials had joined with
Louise Harrison in trying to save the house from the wrecking ball. She
had proposed making it a tourist attraction and turning over proceeds to
the Benton grade schools. But on Monday, Louise Harrison said that
she had lost hope of collecting enough donations by the deadline Sunday.
The state bought the house last year and plans to raze it for a parking
lot for a nearby state office building. The state had held up its plans
to give Harrison's group time to try to raise enough money to either buy
the house and move it, or buy a nearby house to swap with the state for
a parking site.
However, when THE BEATLES balked at having to record someone else's song
as their next single (and John and Paul came up with their own composition
instead...
Parlophone first went to their U.S. sister company, CAPITOL RECORDS, and offered them the single. Capitol passed...so Parlophone shopped it around to smaller, independent labels instead. Having just had some U.S. chart success with placing the FRANK IFIELD hit I REMEMBER YOU with the small, Chicago-based Vee Jay Records, they offered this new release to Vee Jay.
VeeJay was primarily a black artists' label, releasing R&B and Gospel
Records... home to artists like GENE CHANDLER, JERRY BUTLER, DEE CLARK
and, at various times, GLADYS KNIGHT and LITTLE RICHARD. In 1963,
their biggest act was the East Coast '60's Super Group, THE FOUR SEASONS.
When given the opportunity to release
It did nothing...in fact, VeeJay was SO nonchalant about the whole matter that they didn't even spell the name of the group right on the record label. (We covered this a while back in FORGOTTEN HITS...pressings showing the band's name spelled as THE BEATTLES are now worth a FORTUNE!!!) It only stood to reason that the biggest Top 40 rock station in Chicago would pick up a release by a local record label...and, in fact, that's EXACTLY what WLS did. In MARCH of 1963, PLEASE PLEASE ME entered the Silver Dollar Survey...misspelled group name and all...and it debuted at #40 on March 8, 1963. It rode the charts for just two weeks, peaking at #35 on March 15th...but, in that WLS counted down the Top 40 songs on their survey every afternoon, that would mean that THEY played the very first BEATLES record in America...at LEAST three months prior to the downstate Illinois station we told you about yesterday! (According to the INCREDIBLE book SONGS, PICTURES AND STORIES OF THE FABULOUS BEATLES RECORDS ON VEE-JAY, written by BRUCE SPIZER, the original pressing of PLEASE PLEASE ME sold approximately 5650 copies during the first half of 1963...in fact, he says only TWO COPIES of this single were sold during the last six months of that year...a pretty AMAZING fact considering what was about the happen!) This WLS Chart, dated March 8, 1963, shows PLEASE PLEASE ME debuting at #40 (by THE BEATTLES, misspelling their name just like the record label did!) This chart is FIVE FULL MONTHS older than the KRLA Chart we showed you on Tuesday! It says that PLEASE PLEASE ME had been "played on the station" for the past three weeks. Since WLS played their entire Top 40 Countdown everyday (Monday-Friday) from 3:00-6:30 (in fact, at the time, featured jock-of-the-week CLARK WEBER was the guy counting down the hits!) this means that WLS played this song for AT LEAST the two weeks that it charted (and probably more...it peaked the following week at #35). Here is PLEASE PLEASE at #35, its peak position, along with featured jock DICK BIONDI, who WE believe is REALLY the FIRST dj in America to play a BEATLES record! ***NOTE: Special thanks to BILL HENGLES for sending in these cleaned-up WLS survey copies...mine were pretty tattered and worn!!! (Got these JUST in time to include in today's mail!) Thanks, Bill. ***
WLS in Chicago played
"Please Please Me" in February of 1963. It shows up at #40 for the week
of March 8, 1963 and at #35 for the week of March 15, 1963 on their Silver
Dollar Survey. Since it says on the March 8th survey that it had been played
for three weeks, the chances are it had been played since at least the
week of February 22. This corresponds with the release date of the song--
February 25, 1963. Vee Jay was headquartered in Chicago and it stands to
reason they took a copy on that date or perhaps earlier directly to the
station, who probably added it immediately. Dick Biondi claims he was the
first DJ on WLS to play it (new music generally got played on his show)
and therefore was the first DJ in the U.S. to play the Beatles. Art Roberts
never disputed this, but noted that he was so impressed by the song that
he started a Beatles Fan Club then-- the first in the U.S.
Playing the record at the time meant nothing...it didn't even catch on, peaking at #35 and falling off the charts after just two weeks. With 50,000 watts of power, on a clear night, Biondi's show could be heard in most of the 48 continental states and he had a HUGE national following. Odds are, he introduced THE BEATLES to America... and nobody even noticed! For whatever reason, Chicago (and America) just wasn't ready for THE BEATLES yet in March of 1963. (There has ALWAYS been an implied correlation between the assassination of JOHN F. KENNEDY and the arrival of THE BEATLES...Americans needed something to cheer them up, and THE BEATLES happened along at just the right time...I don't think THAT theory will ever go away either!) When PLEASE PLEASE ME was re-released a year later, it went all the way to #2 on that same WLS Silver Dollar Survey! (and ALL the jocks had their photos taken in Beatles wigs, too!) Likewise, in re-release, PLEASE PLEASE ME sold over a million copies...quite a few more than those original 5650 of early 1963. This proof certainly DOES imply that Chicago's very own WLS was the VERY first station in the country to play a BEATLES record on the air! Even if the legendary DICK BIONDI made history that night the first time he played PLEASE PLEASE ME on his radio show, he certainly wasn't aware of it at the time...in fact, since he played new music by new artists never to be heard from again all the time on a regular basis on his program, he may not have even remembered the record in 1964 when BEATLEMANIA exploded. (By the time Beatlemania hit, Biondi wasn't even at WLS anymore! That short window of opportunity had already passed. However, at his NEW gig, ironically at KRLA in Los Angeles, he had the honor of introducing THE BEATLES at their 1965 performance at THE HOLLYWOOD BOWL!) As for ART ROBERTS, it is said that he officially founded BEATLES FAN CLUB #1 here in the United States...he had read about all the fuss they were causing overseas and figured that if they EVER caught on here, at least HE would be able to lay claim to the very first BEATLES U.S. Fan Club. (In another case of irony, it was ART ROBERTS who took over DICK BIONDI's timeslot on WLS after he left the station!) ***
And then this from a site
dedicated to VEE JAY RECORDS: (also courtesy Ron Smith)
Here is a quote from Calvin Carter, the head of Vee Jay Records, regarding the Beatles and WLS: "The Beatles' next British single, "Please Please Me," sailed all the way to #1 by March, 1963. When it hit #2 in early February, Vee Jay decided to release the single here, which they did in late February, 1963, as Vee Jay 498. Oddly enough, nothing at all happened, nationally. The song did get some airplay from Chicago Top-40 giant WLS, and was placed on their Top-40 charts for two weeks, making it the first local Top- 40 appearance for the group in the US. The group was such an unknown that their name was misspelled "Beattles" on the record label and the Top-40 charts." ***
ALAN WILLIAMS managed THE BEATLES from 1960-1961 and was responsible for booking their trips to Hamburg, Germany, where they honed their craft, playing for up to eight hours per night in the seedy Hamburg clubs. Ironically, it was immediately after his dismissal as their manager that renown bandleader BERT KAEMPFERT recruited THE BEATLES to back singer TONY SHERIDAN on some recordings he would be making in Germany. MY BONNIE, recorded during these sessions, was the record that first introduced BRIAN EPSTEIN to THE BEATLES when a youngster ventured into his record shop asking for the record by Liverpool's very own. The rest, as they say, is history. Certainly another of the most famous contenders for the all-time BEATLES' "Hall Of Shame" has to be MIKE SMITH, who turned the BEATLES down for DECCA RECORDS back in 1962 because "groups with guitars were on the way out." He's learned to live with eating those words every day since. (More on the Decca sessions below.) However, here in America, the hands-down LEAD contender for this honor has just GOT to be DAVE DEXTER of Capitol Records. We got the lowdown from BRUCE SPIZERS's INCREDIBLE book THE BEATLES STORY ON CAPITOL RECORDS, PART ONE...wait till you check out THESE facts!!! LOVE ME DO, the first BEATLES single released in Great Britain only went to #17 there, and was never even considered for American release. However, when they recorded PLEASE PLEASE ME, both producer GEORGE MARTIN and Parlophone Records were SURE that this song would be their break-through salvation here in the States. Capitol Records' Dave Dexter, however, turned it down. (He would also turn down their follow-up release, the #1 hit FROM ME TO YOU...years later, he admitted that he didn't like the "harmonica sound" of these two records...previously, he had turned down the Top Five FRANK IFIELD hit I REMEMBER YOU for the same reason!) As such, these singles were shopped around and ultimately sold to Vee Jay Records out of Chicago, a small independent label that released both singles in 1963 with little or no results. When the next BEATLES' single became available, SHE LOVES YOU, Capitol's Dave Dexter AGAIN turned it down, saying it held no appeal to the American music market. This time, the record was leased to Swan Records out of Philadelphia. (Vee Jay was having money problems at the time and had not paid the royalties due on the first two releases...rumor has it that Vee Jay President Ewart Abner had embezzled company funds to pay off his gambling debts and, since the previous releases hadn't done much anyway, chose to ignore any monies due Parlophone.) Once I WANT TO HOLD YOUR HAND was ready for release, Capitol could no longer deny the fact that THIS was going to be a hit record, and it was FINALLY released as the break-through hit that burst the doors open for BEATLEMANIA and the entire BRITISH INVASION that followed. What you may NOT know is that PRIOR to finally releasing I WANT TO HOLD YOUR HAND, Dave Dexter...in his INFINITE wisdom...had ALSO turned down the following British acts on behalf of Capitol Records: GERRY AND THE PACEMAKERS
(signed, instead, by Laurie Records), THE HOLLIES (signed to Imperial),
BILLY J. KRAMER AND THE DAKOTAS (also Imperial), THE ANIMALS (MGM), THE
DAVE CLARK FIVE (Epic), THE SWINGING BLUE JEANS (Imperial again),
The ONLY British act that he felt WORTHY enough of an American release was FREDDIE AND THE DREAMERS, and in 1963, Capitol released I'M TELLING YOU NOW. It tanked...never even charted. Two years later, during the peak of the British Invasion, they re-released the single on their TOWER subsidiary label, and watched it go all the way to #1. (Not surprisingly, by then, FREDDIE's NEW material was being released by Mercury Records!) The distinctive honor of the KING of not only THE BEATLES' Hall of Shame but also the MUSIC Hall Of Shame has just GOT to be Dave Dexter of Capitol Records! BTW: In 1964 alone, the British music that Dexter turned down, did the following on Billboard's American Music Chart: THE BEATLES: SHE LOVES YOU (#1 for 2 weeks) and SIE LIEBT DICH (#97), both released on Swan Records, PLEASE PLEASE ME (#3), FROM ME TO YOU (#41), DO YOU WANT TO KNOW A SECRET? (#2) and THANK YOU GIRL (#35), all released on Vee Jay Records, LOVE ME DO (#1 for one week), P.S. I LOVE YOU (#10), TWIST AND SHOUT (#2) and THERE'S A PLACE (#74), all released on Tollie Records, a subsidiary of Vee Jay Records, WHY (#88) and MY BONNIE (#26), both released on MGM Records (and recorded in 1960 as the backing band to TONY SHERIDAN) and AIN'T SHE SWEET (#19), released on Atco Records, also a 1960 recording. GERRY AND THE PACEMAKERS:
DON'T LET THE SUN CATCH YOU CRYING (#4),
BILLY J. KRAMER AND THE DAKOTAS: LITTLE CHILDREN (#7), BAD TO ME (#9), I'LL KEEP YOU SATISFIED (#30), and FROM A WINDOW (#23) THE HOLLIES: JUST ONE LOOK (#98) (They exploded in 1966 and ran up a string of eight Billboard Top 40 Hits between 1965-1969). THE SWINGING BLUE JEANS: HIPPY HIPPY SHAKE (#24), GOOD GOLLY MISS MOLLY (#43), YOU'RE NO GOOD (#97) THE DAVE CLARK FIVE: GLAD ALL OVER (#6), BITS AND PIECES (#4), I KNEW IT ALL THE TIME (#53), DO YOU LOVE ME (#11), CAN'T YOU SEE THAT SHE'S MINE (#4), BECAUSE (#3), EVERYBODY KNOWS (#15), and ANY WAY YOU WANT IT (#14) (Over a dozen more hits followed in 1965-1967). THE ANIMALS: THE HOUSE OF THE RISING SUN (#1 for three weeks), GONNA SEND YOU BACK TO WALKER (#57), I'M CRYING (#19), BOOM BOOM (#43); they ALSO had a dozen Top 40 Hits between 1965-1968. HERMAN'S HERMITS: I'M INTO SOMETHING GOOD (#13) (They would also have seven more Top Ten hits in 1965, including two #1's: I'M HENRY THE VIII, I AM and MRS. BROWN, YOU'VE GOT A LOVELY DAUGHTER...and placed TEN more hits in Billboard's Top 40 between 1966-1968. THE YARDBIRDS: No hits in 1964, but six Top 40 Hits between 1965-1966, including the classics FOR YOUR LOVE, HEART FULL OF SOUL and I'M A MAN.
(You gotta wonder just how much Dave Dexter was paid to be a Capitol Records
"knowledgeable talent scout"...he cost the company MILLIONS!!!)
IN ALL FAIRNESS:
After THE BEATLES auditioned for Decca Records, Mike Smith was told by
his boss, Dick Rowe, that he could only sign one rock group to the label.
He had also just auditioned BRIAN POOLE AND THE TREMELOES, and THAT was
the group that HE felt would have the better success. In all fairness,
THE BEATLES' audition wasn't the greatest...performing several old standards,
a couple of '50's "covers" (and a few originals that they eventually gave
away to other artists), they didn't put on a very impressive performance.
Besides a bad case of nerves, a "one take" live recording scenario,
and a couple of cracking voices here and there, their January 1st, 1962,
audition didn't quite measure up to what was to be. Here's one of
those rare Decca audition tunes: THREE COOL CATS, a LEIBER-STOLLER
composition originally done by THE COASTERS. It features a GEORGE
HARRISON lead vocal, something he rarely got once THE BEATLES landed a
REAL recording contract.
|